Stay in touch

Struggling with Garmin’s lactate threshold test

Okay, I just finished my Garmin lactate threshold test and I am a bit surprised. My score today is the same as my score on January 17. I am struggling to believe that.

I definitely ran further today than in January. To be able to compare my scores, I always run the same course. Okay, the wind and temperature isn’t always the same, but for the rest there is no difference. Besides, I run a loop, so I have headwind and tailwind.

 

Heart rate zones

The Garmin lactate threshold test is a program in my Garmin Fenix watch. I warm-up for more or less 10 minutes, click a button and my watch tells me to run a couple of minutes within a certain heart rate zone. I don’t know the zones from the top of my head, but every 4 minutes the zone I have to run in, is a bit higher.

There are 5 intervals I have to do. Four of 4 minutes, one of 3 minutes. According to Garmin their watch: ‘uses your user profile information from the initial setup and your VO2 max. estimate to estimate your lactate threshold. The device will automatically detect your lactate threshold during runs at a steady, high intensity with heart rate.’

 

Different data, same result

That’s all fine to me, but how can the results of 2 tests be the same, if my data is so different? I mean, this is the data of January and today for each interval:

  1. 4 minutes: 660 meters – 141 bpm vs. 690 meters – 139 bpm
  2. 4 minutes: 620 meters – 146 bpm vs. 670 meters – 142 bpm
  3. 4 minutes: 700 meters – 150 bpm vs. 740 meters – 152 bpm
  4. 4 minutes: 760 meters – 161 bpm vs. 810 meters – 161 bpm
  5. 3 minutes: 620 meters – 170 bpm vs. 680 meters – 170 bpm

 

So today I ran further in every interval. I ran in total 30 + 50 + 40 + 50 + 60 = 230 meters further. Also my average heart rate was in my first 2 intervals today lower then in January. In interval 3 it was 2 beats per minute higher, yet I ran 40 meters more in that interval. Interval 4 and 5 my heart rate was the same as in January, but I did run 50 meters and 60 meters more. Still, my overall result is the same.

 

Different feeling, same result

It also felt different this time. I remember in January I had to push to get into the higher heart rate zones and it felt hard to finish that last interval. This time it went easy. I could have kept the pace of the last interval, 4 minutes and 26 seconds per kilometer, for a lot longer. Still Garmin tells me my lactate threshold is the same as in January; 167 beats per minute or a pace of 4 minutes and 58 seconds.

I know it’s just a number. It doesn’t say that much, yet it’s a test I do on a regular basis to see if my stamina is improving. I feel it is. Strava says it is. Since my test in January I ran the Houffa Trail, a 23,5 kilometers race in the Ardennes, the Ommerland trail, a 44,5 kilometers race and an ultra in Sussex. And I’m not even talking about all the training I’ve done. That’s why I am struggling to believe Garmin.

I will admit, I’ve been lazy. I’ve been trusting my Garmin. I’ve got another Lactate Threshold test – the one on this website – I can use. It requires a bit of calculation and a bit more time, but I do think it’s a lot more secure. So let’s start using that one. Starting next week, when I will make Sara do one.

Related Columns

Sign up for more Training Tips & Tricks

Newsletter signup

Please wait..

Yeah, you signed up! Now, you'll get the best training tips and greatest gear reviews straight in your inbox. The only thing you have to do yourself, is keep on running.

Latest posts

Courtney Dauwalter starts as she finishes; as the best

Courtney Dauwalter and Raul Butaci have won the Transgrancanaria classic 126 kilometres race (6.804m+).

Daan Coenen is searching for his limits

Daan Coenen went from his first marathon to a 100k Fastest Known Time in a year. An interview about looking for limits.

Remi Bonnet takes over Jornet’s UTMB crown

Kilian Jornet is no longer king of the mountains. UTMB has updated their ranking and the new number one is Remi Bonnet.

Azumi and MacDonald win UTMB Tarawera

Konoka Azumi (Japan) and Adrian MacDonald (United States) have won the UTMB Tarawera Ultra Trail New Zealand 100 miles.

UTMB World Series kicks-off with Tarawera ultra

This weekend, February 17 and 18, the UTMB World kicks off with the Tarawera Ultra-Trail, in Rotorua, New Zealand.

The Race Against Time by Richard Askwith, a review

Can we still be good runners when we get old? Yes, discovers Richard Askwith, in his book The Race Against Time.
Training